One crypto investor filed their ITR, paid tax on his crypto gains, and expected the matter to be closed. Then an Income Tax Department (ITD) notice arrived.
Many taxpayers assume that paying the correct tax automatically means their return will never be questioned. Unfortunately, that’s not always how the system works. An Income Tax notice does not automatically mean you’ve done something wrong. In many cases, it simply means the department wants more information, has found a mismatch, or needs clarification. Understanding why these notices are issued can help you avoid common mistakes when filing your crypto taxes.
Common Triggers for an ITD Notice
When a crypto taxpayer receives a notice after filing, one of three things is usually the trigger behind this:
1. AIS, TIS, and Form 26AS Mismatch
The Annual Information Statement (AIS) aggregates every financial information from various reporting entities, including banks, employers, and other institutions that share data with the Income Tax Department.
For crypto investors, this also includes information reported by Indian exchanges that deduct and report TDS under Section 194S. These reported VDA transactions can appear in your AIS and are compared against the details disclosed in your ITR.
When an ITR is filed, the ITD’s system cross-references the declared trades against what the AIS shows. If the figures do not match, which can happen because of rounding differences, classification disputes, or simply because you missed a transaction, the system will flag it. The notice that follows is typically a defective return notice under Section 139(9) or an automated query under Section 143(1).
According to Ankush Kumar, crypto tax and accounting analyst at KoinX, these notices are generated through an automated matching process. If the transactions reported in your ITR are lower than the information reflected in your AIS, TIS, or Form 26AS, the system can flag the discrepancy, regardless of whether it was caused by an omission or an honest reporting error.
2. Turnover-Based Scrutiny for Derivatives Traders
This one specifically targets crypto futures and options traders, and the threshold is lower than most traders expect.
If you cross the turnover of Rs 10 crore and you are especially dealing in crypto derivatives, chances are likely you’ll get a notice, Kumar says.
The notice in this scenario is a scrutiny notice under Section 143(2), which requires the taxpayer to present a detailed description of their trades, tax computation, and supporting documentation. It is an investigation. The distinction matters because the notice can arrive even if the tax was paid entirely correctly, simply because the scale of activity triggers a mandatory review.
Why Filing Crypto Taxes Correctly Isn't One-Size-Fits-All
A lot of misunderstanding exists about what “filing correctly” means in the context of crypto.
Most Indian crypto platforms, tax calculators, and educational content describe correct filing as: calculate your gains, report them in Schedule VDA, pay 30% tax, submit by July 31. That description is accurate, but it’s not the complete picture.
What it omits is that Schedule VDA addresses only one of the three notice triggers:
- The AIS mismatch trigger requires that the Schedule VDA figures precisely match exchange-reported data, including fees, fractions, and timing differences that most self-filing tools do not reconcile automatically.
- The turnover means futures traders should track their aggregate trading volume, as crossing the relevant threshold can increase the likelihood of receiving a scrutiny notice.
Paying the tax is the minimum, but it is not sufficient. One of the most common reasons for a crypto tax notice is that the figures reported by exchanges in the AIS don’t match what the taxpayer has reported in Schedule VDA.
The difference may be small or significant, but the automated matching system checks for discrepancies regardless of their size. So, a ₹500 difference between what an exchange reported and what appears in the ITR can trigger the same automated flag as a much larger mismatch.
Types of Crypto Tax Notices You May Receive
Not all crypto tax notices are the same. Understanding which type has arrived determines how to respond.
Notice Type | Section | Why It Arrives | Response Timeline |
Defective return / AIS mismatch | Section 139(9) or 143(1) | Filed figures do not match AIS, 26AS, or TIS data | 15 days from notice date |
Scrutiny notice | Section 143(2) | Turnover above threshold, or flagged return selected for review | 30 days, extendable |
Varies; can involve FEMA | |||
Assessment notice | Section 148 | Prior year return reopened due to new information | 30 days
|
A defective return notice under 143(1) is resolved by revising the return with corrected figures and a written explanation. A scrutiny notice under 143(2) requires a detailed response with trade-by-trade documentation.
The good news is that a notice doesn’t always mean it’s too late to fix the problem. If you’re still within the current assessment year, you can usually file a revised return under Section 139(5). For older years, you’ll need to use the updated return route under Section 139(8A), though that involves paying additional tax, which increases the longer you delay.
Kumar points out that the 90% notice probability for Rs 10 crore turnover derivatives traders deserves its own examination, because it is the part of notice risk that is least covered in standard crypto tax education.
How to Stay Compliant
For a crypto investor in India in 2026, “correct” compliance means:
Schedule VDA: Report every taxable crypto disposal with the correct acquisition cost, sale consideration, and gain. If your ITR differs from the information reflected in AIS or other reporting statements, you should be able to explain and support the difference with proper records.
AIS reconciliation: Before filing, download your AIS from the income tax portal and compare it with your crypto transaction records. Check that every VDA transfer reported by Indian exchanges has been considered while preparing your Schedule VDA. If there are differences, make sure you can explain them with supporting records. Since AIS-related mismatches are among the most common reasons for crypto tax notices, reviewing your AIS before filing can help avoid unnecessary queries.
Futures and options classification: If you’ve traded crypto futures or options, get a written opinion from a CA on the correct tax classification. Keep it along with documentation explaining how the platform settles trades, so you can support your position if your return is scrutinised.
This is the kind of problem that feels absurd once it happens and is entirely avoidable if the right information is in front of you before you file.
Where KoinX Fits In
Keeping all these records and reconciling them manually can be time-consuming, especially if you’ve traded across multiple exchanges or wallets. A crypto tax platform makes sure the CA receives accurate, aligned, pre-reconciled data rather than a folder of exchange exports and a request to figure out where the numbers came from.
AIS mismatches often happen because taxpayers prepare their returns from incomplete or manually maintained records. KoinX helps reduce that risk by consolidating transaction data from supported exchanges and wallets into a single tax computation.
Sign up on KoinX and integrate all your wallets to generate a crypto tax report before filing your ITR.
So, instead of comparing multiple spreadsheets, your CA can review one reconciled view before preparing Schedule VDA, making it easier to identify discrepancies before filing your ITR.
KoinX consolidates all your wallets, exchanges, and manual uploads into a single dashboard, pulling every transaction into a unified ledger instead of scattered sources. It then auto-calculates gains and tax liability across all integrations to generate accurate, ready-to-file reports.
So, instead of comparing multiple spreadsheets, your CA can review one reconciled view before preparing Schedule VDA, making it easier to identify discrepancies before filing your ITR.
KoinX prepares a Schedule VDA Report from your exchange data, making it easier to reconcile with your AIS before filing.