The US Tax Court has ruled that crypto staking rewards are taxable when you receive them, not when you sell them. In its June 4, 2026, decision in Paschall v. Commissioner, the court addressed a long-running dispute between crypto investors and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) over when staking rewards become taxable income.
The case involved $33,354 in unreported Cardano staking rewards, for which the IRS sought $24,599 in tax and a $4,920 penalty. This guide explains the case, the court’s reasoning, and its final decision. It also examines which questions about the tax treatment of crypto staking rewards remain unresolved.
Key Takeaways
- The Tax Court held that staking rewards are income in the year you receive them.
- A transfer limit did not delay the tax, because the rewards could still be sold.
- The court rejected comparisons to stock dividends and self-created property.
- The decision rests on Internal Revenue Code (IRC) section 61, not IRS Revenue Ruling 2023-14.
- As a memorandum opinion, Paschall guides future cases but does not bind them.
What Is The Paschall v. Commissioner Case?
Paschall v. Commissioner is a US Tax Court case about crypto staking rewards from tax year 2021. Alvie and Patricia Paschall of California disputed an IRS claim that they owed tax on Cardano rewards. They represented themselves, and Judge Pugh issued the opinion as T.C. Memo. 2026-46.
How Did The Taxpayer Earn Staking Rewards On eToro?
Alvie Paschall held Cardano tokens in an eToro USA account. Cardano runs on a proof-of-stake blockchain, where staked tokens help validate transactions. eToro staked customer tokens by default, though users could opt out. It paid rewards monthly in Cardano and kept 10% to 25% as a fee. He never opted out during 2021.
How Did The Staking Dispute Reach The Tax Court?
eToro reported $33,354 in staking rewards on Form 1099-MISC for 2021. The form went to the couple’s old address, so they never saw it. They first learned of it from a CP2000 notice dated November 13, 2023. A Notice of Deficiency followed on February 5, 2024, and they petitioned the Tax Court.
What Did The Tax Court Rule On Crypto Staking Rewards?
The court ruled that the Cardano rewards were taxable income in 2021, the year they arrived. The Paschalls raised three arguments for delaying the tax until a sale. The court rejected each one, relying on IRC section 61 and long-standing case law on gross income.
Staking Rewards Count As Income On Receipt
Section 61 taxes wealth gains a taxpayer fully controls. The Paschalls argued eToro removed that control. On November 23, 2021, eToro announced it would delist Cardano. It also blocked transfers to other accounts or platforms. Paschall could still sell, but did not. Under Helvering v. Horst, the power to dispose of income equals owning it.
Why The Court Rejected The Stock Dividend Argument
The Paschalls compared staking rewards to the stock dividend in Eisner v. Macomber, which was not taxed on receipt. That dividend added shares without changing any holder’s proportionate interest. Staking rewards worked differently. They increased Paschall’s share of all Cardano in circulation. Not every holder staked, and stakers risked losing tokens to earn rewards.
Why Staking Rewards Are Not Self-Created Property
They also likened staking rewards to a baker’s cake or a writer’s book. Such self-created property is taxed only when sold. The court disagreed, since stakers create nothing. The protocol issues new tokens in exchange for validation. Paschall also did not own or run the staking pool, so he could not control their creation.
Paschall Arguments Vs. Court Findings At A Glance
The table below sums up how the court answered each taxpayer argument.
|
Taxpayer Argument |
Court’s Answer |
|
The transfer restriction removed dominion and control |
Rewards could be sold for cash at any time, which is control enough |
|
Rewards are like nontaxable stock dividends |
Rewards raised the holder’s share and value of Cardano |
|
Rewards are self-created property |
Stakers create nothing, because the protocol issues the tokens |
What Was The Final Outcome Of The Paschall Case?
The Paschalls lost on staking but ended with a much smaller bill. The final decision, entered on August 6, 2026, set the deficiency at $8,094. It imposed no accuracy-related penalty under section 6662(a). That compares with the $24,599 tax and $4,920 penalty the IRS first sought.
How The Court Decided The Case Without A Trial?
The case never went to trial. A San Francisco trial was set for May 19, 2025, but the court continued it. The parties instead submitted the case on agreed facts under Tax Court Rule 122. Neither side offered expert testimony, a gap the court said hampered its analysis of crypto mechanics.
Why The Final Tax Bill Dropped?
The opinion notes that the parties made concessions before the court ruled. That left staking income as the only issue to decide. Because of those concessions, the court ordered a Tax Court Rule 155 computation. Under that rule, both sides calculate the exact tax owed from the court’s findings. That calculation produced the $8,094 figure.
Why Did The Tax Court Not Rely On IRS Revenue Ruling 2023-14?
The court did not need the revenue ruling to reach its answer. The taxpayers attacked Revenue Ruling 2023-14 as invalid and retroactive. The court sidestepped that fight. Section 61 and related case law already taxed the rewards on receipt.
What Revenue Ruling 2023-14 Says About Staking?
The IRS issued this ruling in 2023 for cash-method taxpayers who stake crypto. Validation rewards are income once you gain dominion and control over them. That means the ability to sell, exchange, or otherwise dispose of the rewards. Income equals their fair market value at that moment. The rule also covers staking through an exchange.
Why The Court Relied On Section 61 Instead?
The Paschalls cited Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, a 2024 Supreme Court case on agency deference. They also argued that 2023 guidance could not reach their 2021 income. The court declined to decide either point. The IRS itself said it did not directly rely on the ruling. So the ruling’s validity remains an open question.
How Does Paschall Relate To The Jarrett Staking Case?
Jarrett is the other well-known staking dispute, and the Paschalls cited it for support. A married couple, the Jarretts, argued that staking rewards are taxed only when sold. Their first case ended without a ruling on that question. Paschall now gives stakers the court reasoning that Jarrett never produced.
The Jarretts sued for a refund of tax paid on staking rewards from their 2019 return. Before the district court ruled, the government approved their refund and mailed a check. The court then dismissed the case as moot. In 2023, the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed that dismissal, leaving the merits undecided.
Where Jarrett II Stands Today?
In October 2024, the Jarretts filed a second refund suit for tax year 2020. A Congressional Research Service (CRS) report updated September 21, 2026, gives its status. Both sides have summary judgment motions pending. The case sits in the US District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee. No trial date has been set.
Why The Jarrett Refund Does Not Bind The Tax Court
The Paschalls pointed to the Jarrett refund as proof that staking rewards escape tax until sale. The Tax Court disagreed in a footnote. It noted that the Jarrett court never addressed the merits of those arguments. A refund conceded in one case also does not bind the Tax Court in another.
Is The Paschall Ruling Binding On All Crypto Investors?
No. Paschall binds only the taxpayers in that case. As a memorandum opinion, it can be cited as persuasive legal authority. The opinion rests on section 61 and case law, not Revenue Ruling 2023-14. Stakers who skip reporting rewards on receipt should expect the IRS to cite it.
How Much Weight Does A Tax Court Memorandum Opinion Carry?
The Tax Court issues division opinions and memorandum opinions. Memorandum opinions usually apply settled law to specific facts. According to the CRS report, the court has said they are not controlling precedent. Another judge may reach a different result on new facts. A case with expert testimony on blockchain mechanics could also test this reasoning.
Can The Paschall Ruling Still Be Appealed?
Yes, for a short time. Under IRC section 7483, either side has 90 days from the decision to file an appeal. The decision here was entered on August 6, 2026. That window runs into early November 2026. Because the couple lives in California, an appeal would go to the Ninth Circuit.
Could Congress Change How Crypto Staking Is Taxed In The US?
Yes, if Congress passes new legislation. The CRS report lists several 2026 bills aimed at clarifying how digital assets are taxed. One of them would directly reverse the Paschall result for stakers. Until any bill becomes law, the court’s rule and the IRS position govern your crypto return.
The Tax Clarity For Mining And Staking Act
Representative Mike Carey introduced H.R. 9175 on June 8, 2026. It would defer income from crypto mining and staking until you dispose of the tokens. Stakers would then pay tax at sale rather than on receipt. That outcome mirrors the argument the Jarretts made in court.
The Digital Asset Tax Certainty Act
H.R. 10357 takes a wider approach to crypto taxes. The House Ways and Means Committee ordered it reported on September 16, 2026. Among other changes, it would drop the qualified appraisal requirement for donations of widely traded digital assets. The full House and the Senate must still act before it can take effect.
How KoinX Helps You Track Crypto Staking Rewards?
Staking rewards often arrive daily or monthly, each at a different market price. A year of rewards can mean hundreds of small income entries. Paschall shows the IRS will tax every one of them, whether you sell or not. KoinX pulls data from 800+ integrations and values each reward on the day it lands.
Income Summary Report For Staking Income
The Income Summary Report lists staking rewards under its Other Income section. Each reward is valued at its fair market value at the time of receipt. That matches the timing the Tax Court applied in Paschall. You get one income figure for the year instead of hundreds of entries.
Complete Tax Report For Your Full Crypto Year
The Complete Tax Report brings staking income, capital gains, and Form 8949 data into one file. It also shows your holdings at the start and end of the tax year. Use it with the Form 8949 or TurboTax report when you file. Your preparer then sees every reward alongside your trades.
Transaction History Report For Every Reward
The Transaction History report lists every imported transaction, including each staking reward, with its date. That record helps if the IRS questions a figure on your return. The Paschall dispute began with an information return the Paschalls never saw. A full history lets you check platform forms against your own records.
Under Paschall, every staking reward counts as income on the day it reaches your account. Sign up on KoinX to value each reward at receipt and keep your staking income ready.
Conclusion
Paschall settles one point for now: staking rewards are income on receipt, even if you never sell. Other questions stay open, including the validity of Revenue Ruling 2023-14 and the fate of pending bills. Skipping rewards on your return can still lead to penalties for unreported crypto.
Until those questions are resolved, report rewards in the year they arrive. Do not wait for a platform form either, since the Paschalls never received theirs. Track your staking rewards on KoinX so each one carries a value and date.
Frequently Asked Questions
How Long Can The IRS Assess Tax On Unreported Staking Rewards?
The IRS generally has three years from the later of your filing date or due date. Internal Revenue Manual (IRM) 25.6.23 explains these limits under IRC section 6501. The period grows to six years if you omit over 25% of your reported gross income. No limit applies to a fraudulent return or no return.
Will Form 1099-DA Report Your Staking Rewards?
Not for now. IRS Notice 2024-57 pauses broker reporting on staking transactions that occur on or after January 1, 2025. The notice adds that rewards may still fall under other reporting rules. Whether or not a form arrives, you must report every reward yourself.
Does The Paschall Ruling Cover Staking Pool Operators?
Not directly. Paschall was an exchange customer, not the owner or operator of a staking pool. The court relied on that fact when it rejected the self-created property argument. It did not decide how solo validators or pool operators should treat newly issued tokens. That question remains open for future cases.
What Should You Do If You Receive A CP2000 For Staking Income?
Respond by the date on the notice. If you agree, sign the response form and arrange payment. If you disagree, send a statement with supporting records. An unresolved CP2000 can lead to a Notice of Deficiency, as it did for the Paschalls. Our guide to IRS notices compares CP2000 with Letters 6173 and 6174.