In the 2026 Independent Reserve Cryptocurrency Index, 32% of crypto investors put in A$500 or more monthly. Regular buying like that leaves investors holding the same coin at many different prices. So when they sell, which coins did they actually sell? The answer changes the capital gain, and the tax, on every sale.
The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) has no crypto-specific rule here. For shares, it accepts your own parcel choice or first in, first out (FIFO). FIFO suits identical units that cannot be told apart, giving an objective order. Neither is mandatory for crypto, so this guide applies both by analogy, covering the 50% discount too.
Key Takeaways
- The ATO has no crypto-specific rule for deciding which coins you sold first.
- For shares, it accepts your chosen parcels, or FIFO where units cannot be identified.
- Selling older coins can keep the 50% discount, while newer coins may lose it.
- Records of every purchase and every sale are needed to support your chosen method.
Why Does It Matter Which Crypto You Sell First?
It matters because each purchase of the same coin can carry a different cost and date. Whichever purchase a sale is matched to sets its cost base. It also decides whether the 12-month mark for the discount has been reached. One sale can produce very different results depending on that match.
Buying At Different Prices Creates Different Gains
Suppose you bought Bitcoin three times over two years, each time at a different price. When you later sell part of that holding, its proceeds are fixed. The cost base is not, because it depends on which purchase the sale draws from. Match it to a cheap purchase and the gain grows.
Why Identical Coins Still Need Identifying
Every Bitcoin is interchangeable with every other, so no coin carries its own label. The ATO still treats each crypto asset as a separate capital gains tax (CGT) asset. Your tax return therefore needs a clear link between each sale and a specific purchase. That link is exactly what a parcel selection method provides.
What Is Parcel Selection And How Does The ATO Treat It?
Parcel selection is the rule you use to match each crypto sale to an earlier purchase. The term comes from the ATO’s published guidance on shares and units. The ATO has not published equivalent guidance specifically for crypto. That gap shapes how each of the methods below should be applied.
What The ATO Means By A Parcel?
In its fact sheet on selling shares, the ATO calls each distinct batch a parcel. Buying the same company’s shares at different times creates several parcels. Together, those parcels make up your total holding. For crypto, each purchase of the same coin forms a parcel with its own date and price.
How Parcel Selection Works For Crypto?
When you sell part of a holding, you decide which parcel the coins came from. That parcel’s purchase price becomes the cost base for the sale. Its purchase date sets the holding period used for the discount. The parcels you do not sell stay behind, carrying their own costs into future sales.
The ATO's Approach For Shares And Units
The ATO’s guidance on identifying shares or units sold starts with your records. Where they identify the parcel sold, that parcel is used. Where they cannot, the ATO accepts your own selection or a FIFO basis. Averaging costs is allowed only in limited cases, such as identical shares bought the same day.
Applying The Share Approach To Crypto
Some investors and advisers apply the share approach to crypto by analogy. In practice, that means relying on the same two options: your own selection or FIFO. Treat any method as a reasoned choice, not a rule the ATO has set for crypto. A registered tax agent can confirm whether your approach suits your situation.
What Are The Common Parcel Selection Methods?
The ATO’s shares fact sheet names three common parcel selection methods for investors. A fourth approach, choosing specific parcels, follows from the ATO accepting your own selection. Each method sorts the same purchases in a different order. That order decides which cost base and holding period each sale receives.
First In, First Out (FIFO)
First in, first out treats the coins you bought earliest as the first ones sold. The ATO notes most people use FIFO because it is the easiest to track. For long-term holders, the oldest coins are usually past the 12-month mark. In a rising market, however, they also carry the lowest cost base.
Last In, First Out (LIFO)
Last in, first out treats your most recent purchase as the first one sold. In a rising market, recent coins often cost more, so gains tend to be smaller. Recent purchases are also less likely to have been held for 12 months. A smaller gain can therefore arrive without the discount.
Highest In, First Out (HIFO)
Highest in, first out treats your most expensive purchase as the first one sold, whenever it happened. The ATO’s fact sheet also calls it highest cost, first out. It usually produces the smallest gain on a single sale. The trade-off is that cheaper parcels remain, lifting future gains when they are sold.
Specific Identification
Specific identification means choosing the exact parcel for each sale yourself. It relies on the ATO accepting your own selection of units disposed of. This gives the most control, since you can pick parcels by both cost and age. It also demands the clearest records of what was chosen and why.
How Does Your Choice Affect The 50% CGT Discount?
Your choice affects the discount because each purchase carries its own holding period. Two coins sold on the same day can receive very different treatment. One may qualify for the discount while the other does not. That is why methods should be compared after the discount is applied, not before.
The 12-Month Holding Rule
Under the ATO’s CGT discount rules, individuals can reduce a capital gain by 50%. The asset must be owned for at least 12 months before the CGT event. With parcel selection, that clock runs separately for every purchase. A sale matched to a purchase made 11 months earlier gets no discount at all.
When FIFO Keeps The Discount
FIFO sells your oldest coins first, so the 12-month mark is usually passed. That typically halves the taxable part of the gain. The catch is that older coins often cost least, so the raw gain is larger. Even after halving, FIFO can leave a bigger taxable amount than other methods.
When HIFO Lowers The Gain But Loses The Discount
HIFO picks your most expensive coins, which often means your most recent ones. The raw gain shrinks, but coins held under 12 months receive no discount. Sometimes the smaller undiscounted gain still wins, and sometimes it does not. The only way to know is to compare the net figures side by side.
Comparing Methods On One Sale
Consider a hypothetical investor who bought 0.5 Bitcoin (BTC) three times. Parcel A cost A$25,000 in February 2024, and Parcel B cost A$40,000 in August 2025. Parcel C cost A$50,000 in March 2026. In September 2026, the investor sells 0.5 BTC for A$55,000, with no other gains or losses. Fees are ignored for simplicity.
Method | Parcel Treated As Sold | Selling Price | Cost Base | Capital Gain | 50% Discount | Net Capital Gain |
FIFO | Parcel A (February 2024) | A$55,000 | A$25,000 | A$30,000 | Yes | A$15,000 |
LIFO | Parcel C (March 2026) | A$55,000 | A$50,000 | A$5,000 | No | A$5,000 |
HIFO | Parcel C (Highest Cost) | A$55,000 | A$50,000 | A$5,000 | No | A$5,000 |
Specific Identification | Parcel B (August 2025) | A$55,000 | A$40,000 | A$15,000 | Yes | A$7,500 |
Here, LIFO and HIFO give the lowest result, even without the discount. FIFO produces the highest, despite halving its gain. Parcels A and B remain, though, so their lower costs raise future gains. Change the prices or dates, and a different method could come out ahead. Every sale needs its own comparison.
How Does Your Choice Affect Capital Losses?
Your choice can also create a capital loss where a different method would show a gain. That happens when a sale is matched to coins bought above the selling price. Losses follow their own set of rules, so they are worth understanding separately. Timing and method work closely together here.
Selling Higher-Cost Coins To Realise A Loss
Suppose the price has fallen below what you paid for your most recent coins. Matching a sale to them produces a capital loss, even if older coins show profit. The ATO notes you can only claim a loss on assets actually disposed of. Your remaining, cheaper coins then carry a larger gain into the future.
Using Losses Against Current-Year Gains
A capital loss first reduces capital gains made in the same income year. Any unused amount carries forward indefinitely, but it cannot reduce salary or wages. Losses reduce gains before the discount is applied, which affects how much the discount is worth. Our guide to crypto tax-loss harvesting explains how to time these sales.
What Records Do You Need To Support Your Choice?
Whatever method you use, your records must show how each sale was matched. Without them, your chosen parcels cannot be proven if the ATO ever asks. The ATO’s crypto record-keeping guidance sets the baseline for what to keep. Parcel selection adds a few extra details on top of that list.
Records Of Every Purchase
Each purchase needs its date, quantity and cost in Australian dollars. Fees paid then also form part of its cost base. Treat every purchase as its own parcel, even small top-up buys. For regular buyers, that can mean dozens of parcels each year. Missing one purchase can shift every later match out of order.
Recording Which Coins Were Sold
For every sale, note which parcel it was matched to and why. Record the sale date, proceeds and the method used. This note turns a spreadsheet choice into evidence. Records should be kept for at least five years after the sale. Losses need records until they are used, plus a further two years.
Staying Consistent Across Years
Switching methods from sale to sale can make records harder to follow. A parcel treated as sold once cannot be sold again later. Keeping a running list of remaining parcels across years prevents double counting. Whatever approach you take, apply it deliberately and document each decision. Consistency makes your figures far easier to defend.
How Can KoinX Help You Choose Which Crypto To Sell First?
Comparing methods by hand means rebuilding every parcel and every sale in a spreadsheet. Regular buyers can end up with hundreds of rows before a single sale. KoinX tracks each purchase and applies your chosen method under ATO rules. The reports and features below make that comparison practical rather than painful.
Buy Sell Report
The Buy Sell Report shows every buy, sell and swap in one place. Each buy line is effectively a parcel, with its own date and price. Seeing them together makes it easy to spot which purchases passed the 12-month mark. Swaps appear alongside buys and sells, so no disposal is left unmatched.
Complete ATO Tax Report
The Complete ATO Tax Report applies ATO rules to your crypto data, including CGT discounts. It separates short-term gains from long-term gains, which clearly shows where the discount applied. That split directly reflects the parcel selection method you chose. Detailed portfolio balances sit alongside, showing what remains for future sales.
Multiple Accounting Methods
The platform supports FIFO, LIFO, HIFO and average cost basis, with FIFO recommended for Australians. Switching away from FIFO triggers an on-screen warning advising you to consult a tax expert. Averaging needs care, as the ATO allows it only in limited cases. FIFO is also the ATO’s fallback for shares.
Accurate Preview
Accurate Preview displays your capital gains while you step through each transaction. After switching methods, it lets you check the effect on each sale before any report is generated. That makes comparisons like the table above quick to repeat with real data. Errors spotted here are far cheaper to fix than after lodging.
Choosing which crypto to sell first works best with real numbers in front of you. Import every exchange and wallet so each purchase becomes a trackable parcel. Then compare methods before you sell, not after the financial year ends. Compare your parcel selection options with KoinX before your next sale.
Conclusion
Decide which crypto you are selling before the sale, not months later at tax time. Check which parcels have passed 12 months and what each one costs. A sale delayed by a few weeks can sometimes unlock the discount. Small timing choices like that can matter as much as the method itself.
Record every decision about which coins you sold as you make it. Your chosen parcels, dates and reasons will be the evidence behind every figure. With the 2027 changes approaching, clear parcel records will matter even more. Track every parcel on KoinX and sell each coin with its tax outcome already known.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I Use A Different Parcel Selection Method For Each Sale?
For shares, yes. The ATO’s fact sheet says a different method may be applied for each parcel sold. Applying the same flexibility to crypto is a reasonable analogy, not an ATO statement. Whatever you choose, record the method used for every sale. Frequent switching without notes makes your figures hard to verify.
What If My Records Do Not Show Purchase Prices?
Without purchase prices, no parcel selection method can work properly. Exchange support teams and blockchain explorers can help recover missing details. Bank statements can also confirm the Australian dollars paid for each purchase. Rebuild each purchase before choosing any method. Our guide to reconstructing missing cost base records walks through the full process.
Do Transfers Between My Wallets Change Which Coins Count As Sold?
No. Moving crypto between wallets you own is not a disposal. Each parcel keeps its original purchase date and cost after the transfer. Problems arise when software treats the arriving coins as a new purchase. That resets dates and costs, which can wrongly remove the discount from older coins sold later.
Does Parcel Selection Apply To Crypto-To-Crypto Swaps?
Yes. A swap is a disposal of the crypto you give up, under the ATO’s crypto transactions guidance. You still need to decide which parcel of that coin was used. The coin you receive then starts a new parcel at its market value. Frequent swappers can build up many parcels quickly.