As Form 1099-DA broker reporting takes effect for the 2025 tax year, crypto investor recordkeeping has moved from a background obligation to a front-line enforcement issue. The gap between what investors actually track and what the IRS now receives from exchanges is exposing years of incomplete cost basis records, misunderstood taxable events, and structural recordkeeping failures across millions of U.S. accounts. Globally, the picture is similarly fragmented: multi-wallet ownership, decentralized finance activity, and cross-chain transactions have outpaced the recordkeeping habits of most retail investors.
At KoinX, we work directly with crypto investors navigating exactly these gaps, and the data compiled below reflects the scale of the challenge facing both individual filers and the compliance infrastructure designed to support them.
This article draws on the latest surveys, government filings, regulatory disclosures, and institutional research published in 2024 and 2025 to document where crypto recordkeeping stands as of 2026, across investor behavior, cost basis accuracy, compliance awareness, enforcement exposure, and tool adoption.
Scope & Methodology
Statistics in this article are drawn exclusively from primary sources: government agency data and official IRS guidance documents, peer-reviewed institutional research from the JPMorgan Chase Institute, primary survey research from Coinbase and CoinTracker’s 2026 Crypto Tax Readiness Report (3,000 U.S. respondents, September to October 2025), the Motley Fool 2025 Cryptocurrency Investor Trends Survey, the Security.org 2026 Cryptocurrency Adoption and Sentiment Report, Kraken’s 2024 investor survey (1,146 U.S. respondents), and official U.S. Treasury and Joint Committee on Taxation estimates. Market research figures from Deloitte and the AICPA Tax Adviser were included where they cite original government enforcement data.
Recency was enforced through a 2024-2026 publication window. All original study years are retained in each bullet. Each statistic is presented atomically, one data point per bullet, with no synthesis or inference. Limitations include the self-reported nature of many behavioral surveys and the evolving first-year 1099-DA data environment in which baseline compliance benchmarks remain provisional.
Recordkeeping Compliance at a Glance: 2026 Numbers
- 61% of U.S. crypto users were unaware of specific new IRS tax rules for 2025, including the Form 1099-DA requirement, based on a survey of 3,000 U.S. crypto investors conducted between September and October 2025, according to the 2026 Crypto Tax Readiness Report by Coinbase and CoinTracker.
- Only 49% of U.S. crypto investors correctly understand that a tax obligation arises specifically when they sell crypto, while nearly 25% mistakenly believe simple wallet-to-wallet transfers trigger taxable events, based on the same 3,000-person survey, according to the 2026 Crypto Tax Readiness Report.
- The U.S. Treasury’s Joint Committee on Taxation estimated that mandatory digital asset broker reporting enacted under the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act would raise nearly $28 billion over 10 years by closing crypto tax reporting gaps, according to the U.S. Treasury press release of August 25, 2023.
- Approximately 30% of U.S. adults, or 70.4 million people, owned cryptocurrency in 2026, up from 27% in 2024, according to the Security.org 2026 Cryptocurrency Adoption and Sentiment Report published January 2026.
- 17% of active Chase checking account holders had transferred funds to crypto accounts at some point between January 2017 and May 2025, with the median size of direct investments remaining below 1 week’s worth of income, according to the JPMorgan Chase Institute’s August 2025 research report on retail crypto investor behavior.
- Between 13 million and 16 million U.S. taxpayers are expected to receive at least 1 Form 1099-DA for 2025 transactions, according to the IRS’s own estimates cited in its final digital asset broker reporting regulations published July 9, 2024.
- The IRS collected $235 million in unpaid crypto taxes in 2024, reflecting rising detection rates from exchange data requests and blockchain analytics, according to CoinLaw’s 2025 crypto tax evasion case statistics report.
- CoinLedger reported a 758% increase in IRS warning letters (Letters 6174 and 6174-A) sent to crypto holders over a 60-day period in mid-2025, according to Delia Tax Attorneys’ July 2025 analysis citing CoinLedger enforcement data.
- The global crypto tax software market was projected to grow from $4,450 million in 2024 to $24,809 million by 2032 at a CAGR of 23.96%, with North America holding 38% of global market share in 2024, according to Credence Research’s July 2025 market report.
- U.S. crypto investors averaged 2.5 platforms or wallets per person in the September to October 2025 survey period, with 83% using self-custodial wallets, according to the 2026 Crypto Tax Readiness Report by Coinbase and CoinTracker.
- 71% of U.S. crypto users had moved crypto between wallets at some point, but only 35% had properly adjusted their cost basis after doing so, creating a 36-percentage-point gap in cross-wallet recordkeeping compliance, according to the 2026 Crypto Tax Readiness Report by Coinbase and CoinTracker (3,000-person survey, 2025).
- 65% of U.S. crypto investors had previously reported crypto activity on their taxes, while 15% had not yet had any taxable events such as sales or swaps, and 10% did not believe their activity was taxable, according to the 2026 Crypto Tax Readiness Report by Coinbase and CoinTracker (2025 survey).
- 74% of U.S. crypto users know that their crypto activity is taxable, yet only 56% rated their knowledge of the specific crypto tax rules as good or excellent, according to the 2026 Crypto Tax Readiness Report by Coinbase and CoinTracker (3,000-person survey, 2025).
- 83% of U.S. crypto holders held investments outside of crypto including stocks, bonds, and real estate, according to the 2026 Crypto Tax Readiness Report (2025 survey, 3,000 respondents).
- Among 1,146 U.S. crypto holders surveyed in June 2024, 73% planned to continue investing in crypto through 2025 and 70% preferred established coins like Bitcoin, with the survey conducted with a 95% confidence level and a +/- 3% margin of error, according to Kraken’s 2024 investor survey.
- 11% of survey respondents claimed to understand how cryptocurrency works very well in a 2025 survey, down from 18% in 2024 and 24% in 2022, while 38% said they do not understand how crypto works at all, up from 33% in 2024 and 19% in 2022, according to the Motley Fool 2025 Cryptocurrency Investor Trends Survey.
Cost Basis Tracking Errors and Record Gaps
- The IRS’s 2019 tax gap analysis, cited in its 2024 final 1099-DA regulations, found that net income misreporting for categories with little or no third-party reporting stands at 55%, compared with 17% misreporting for income with some information reporting such as capital gains, and just 5% for income with substantial reporting such as dividends, according to IRS final regulations published July 9, 2024.
- 44% of U.S. crypto holders surveyed in 2024 were unaware that swapping one cryptocurrency for another constitutes a taxable event, contributing to widespread unreported gain from token-to-token trades, according to CoinLaw’s 2025 crypto tax evasion case statistics report.
- Approximately $10 to $15 billion is estimated to be lost annually by the U.S. in tax revenue from unreported crypto activity, with global crypto tax gaps potentially exceeding $40 billion by 2025 when factoring in DeFi, staking, and tokenized income streams, according to CoinLaw’s 2025 crypto tax evasion statistics report.
- For a $100,000 unreported crypto gain, total tax liability including taxes, accuracy penalties, and interest could reach $98,500+, compared with approximately $28,000 if properly reported and paid, according to Astraea Counsel’s October 2025 crypto tax lawyer guide.
IRS Enforcement and Non-Compliance Data
- The IRS announced on September 8, 2023 that it identified a 75% non-compliance rate among digital asset taxpayers identified through records obtained from cryptocurrency exchanges, citing this as a primary driver of expanded crypto audit and examination efforts beginning in fiscal year 2024, according to the IRS press release IR-2023-166 cited in Deloitte’s 2024 IRS exam preparation guidance.
- Penalties for failure to report 2025 cryptocurrency transactions include accuracy-related penalties equal to 20% of understated tax, failure-to-file penalties reaching 25% of unpaid taxes, and fraud penalties up to 75% for willful evasion, according to tax compliance firm Instead.com’s 2025 tax year guide to cryptocurrency reporting.
- A Pennsylvania resident pleaded guilty in 2025 to underreporting over $13 million in NFT sales from CryptoPunks proceeds, while a separate individual admitted to hiding $2.6 million in crypto income, resulting in felony charges, according to Delia Tax Attorneys’ July 2025 analysis of IRS enforcement actions.
- Among audited filers in 2024, crypto users showed a 4x higher noncompliance rate compared to traditional investors, with noncompliance found across income levels and not concentrated exclusively among high-net-worth individuals, according to CoinLaw’s 2025 crypto tax evasion case statistics report.
- $2.3 billion was recovered by the IRS from offshore crypto accounts in 2025 through enhanced international investigations, according to CoinLaw’s 2025 crypto tax evasion case statistics report.
Compliance Awareness Gaps
- 16% of U.S. crypto users said they did not know what adjusting cost basis means, while an additional 41% said they knew about cost basis adjustments but had never actually performed them, according to the 2026 Crypto Tax Readiness Report by Coinbase and CoinTracker (3,000-person survey, September to October 2025).
- 40% of survey respondents in 2025 would consider investing in cryptocurrency through a retirement account, down from 44% in 2024 despite Bitcoin reaching record levels, according to the Motley Fool 2025 Cryptocurrency Investor Trends Survey.
- 53% of people who have ever owned crypto reported a positive return on their investments, while 21% experienced a net loss, and 61% of current crypto owners planned to buy more in 2026, according to the Security.org 2026 Cryptocurrency Adoption and Sentiment Report published January 2026.
- 69% of all survey respondents in 2025 believed the U.S. government had not done enough to regulate cryptocurrencies, while 61% of current crypto holders believed existing regulation was sufficient, reflecting a sharp divide between owners and non-owners on compliance frameworks, according to the Motley Fool 2025 Cryptocurrency Investor Trends Survey.
- Only 46% of retail crypto holders in a 2024 survey felt fully confident managing their own key recovery for self-custodial wallets, despite 71% reporting increased awareness of self-custody in 2025, according to CoinLaw’s November 2025 self-custody wallet statistics report.
DeFi, NFT, and Multi-Chain Recordkeeping Failures
- NFT trading volume totaled $24 billion in 2024, yet only a fraction of those gains appeared in filed tax returns, according to CoinLaw’s 2025 crypto tax evasion case statistics report.
- 198 million wallets were active in DeFi in 2025, approximately 24% of all crypto wallets globally, with the average DeFi wallet supporting approximately 5.4 tokens and interacting across approximately 2.3 chains, according to CoinLaw’s November 2025 self-custody wallet statistics report.
- Under IRS Notice 2024-57, brokers are not required to report on Form 1099-DA for 6 specific transaction types including on-chain swaps, smart contract interactions, staking rewards, and DeFi-native mechanics occurring outside custodial broker platforms, meaning these activities remain entirely dependent on self-reported investor records, according to the IRS official digital assets guidance page as of 2025.
- President Trump signed legislation on April 10, 2025 nullifying IRS rules that would have required decentralized finance brokers to file Form 1099-DA, exempting decentralized exchanges, non-custodial wallet providers, and permissionless infrastructure from broker reporting obligations, with the repeal applying to platforms that processed an estimated $6.7 trillion in decentralized perpetual futures volume in 2025, according to TaxPlanIQ’s March 2026 crypto tax update.
- Staking rewards are classified as taxable income in approximately 75% of major global tax frameworks, yet staking income is frequently unreported in DeFi yield farming activities, according to CoinLaw’s 2025 crypto tax evasion case statistics report.
- Assets transferred between wallets, across chains, or through decentralized exchanges generate no broker-issued basis documentation, requiring taxpayers to reconstruct cost basis independently, with missing basis defaulting to $0 under IRS methodology resulting in 100% of proceeds being treated as taxable gain, according to IRS Form 1099-DA guidance and Chainwise CPA’s January 2026 analysis of the 1099-DA framework.
- 78% of U.S. crypto users relied on general tax software and 52% used accountants for their 2025 tax filings, while only 8% used crypto-specific tax reconciliation tools despite the complexity of wallet-by-wallet cost basis tracking required under IRS Rev. Proc. 2024-28, according to the 2026 Crypto Tax Readiness Report by Coinbase and CoinTracker (2025 survey).
- CoinTracker supports 500+ exchange and wallet integrations and tracks more than 10,000 cryptocurrencies for 3 million+ users, with advanced plans supporting up to 250,000 transactions per tax year for high-volume traders, according to CoinLaw’s January 2026 CoinTracker statistics report.
- CoinTracker reported $23.1 million in revenue in 2025, more than doubling from $9 million in 2024, reflecting strong growth in demand for automated crypto tax reconciliation tools as Form 1099-DA obligations took effect, according to CoinLaw’s January 2026 CoinTracker statistics report.
- 47% of U.S. crypto users surveyed in 2025 said they would use AI to calculate taxable income, cost basis, and capital gains, 43% said they would use AI for tax strategy recommendations, and 30% said they would be comfortable using AI for their entire tax process, according to the 2026 Crypto Tax Readiness Report by Coinbase and CoinTracker.
- DIY crypto tax software costs $49 to $3,499 annually depending on transaction volume, while hiring a crypto-specialized CPA costs $500 to $5,000 for returns with under 100 transactions and $5,000 to $15,000+ for complex returns involving DeFi, staking, NFTs, and multiple wallets, with tax attorneys charging $200 to $550 per hour for audit defense, according to Astraea Counsel’s October 2025 crypto tax lawyer guide.
References
![[object Object]](/_next/static/media/ISO_27001-2022_certification.ae776691.svg)
![[object Object]](/_next/static/media/GDPR_Compliance.a2dc5933.svg)
![[object Object]](/_next/static/media/SOC_2_Type_II_certification.dd69381e.svg)
